Armour Reviews
Tamiya T-55A Russian Medium Tank
Home
ABER 75mm KwK 42 Panther Gun Barrel
ABER Early Model Shackle for Pz.Kpfw. V Panther
Academy M36 Jackson GMC
Academy M9 Dozer Blade
AFV Club .30 Cal/.50 Cal/40mm Ammo Boxes
AFV Club T158 "Bigfoot" Tracks
Armour Track Models T156 Tracks
Armour Track Models T-54/T-55/T-62 Tracks
Armour Track Models T91E3 Tracks for M41/M42
ATAK Models Panzerkampfwagen VI (P) Zimmerit
Bradley by R. P. Hunnicutt
British Tanks in Normandy by Ludovic Fortin
CMK T-72A1 Exterior Detail Set
Combat History of the 10. Panzer-Division by J. Restayn and N. Moller
DML Panther A Early Type (Italy 1943/44)
DML 1/72 Tiger I Late Production with Zimmerit
Dragon Wagon by David Doyle and Pat Stansell
The Duster by David Doyle
Easy 1 Productions CD Electronic Technical Manuals by Mike Powell
Easy 1 Productions CD Electronic Maintenance Manuals by Mike Powell
Eduard T-72 Gun Barrel
FAQ by Mig Jimenez
Fifty Years of the Royal Australian Armoured Corps by Paul Handel
High Speed Tractor by David Doyle and Pat Stansell
ICM 100mm BS-3 Anti-Tank Gun
Late War U.S. Tanks by David Doyle
LionMarc Model Designs 1/35 Sherman Brass Skids
Look Inside Cross Sections: Tanks by Ian Harvey
M2/M3 Half-track Walk Around by Jim Mesko
M3 Lee by David Doyle
M5 and M5A1 Stuart Light Tank by David Doyle
M18 Hellcat Tank Destroyer 1943-97 by Steven J. Zaloga
M-36 Jackson by David Doyle
MIG Productions Early Panther D Grills
MIG Productions T55 Mantlet Without Sand Cover
Modeling Artisan Mori Panther D/A Radiator Inserts
Modelling the Early Panzerkampfwagen IV by Tom Cockle
Modelling Waffen-SS Figures by Calvin Tan
Modelling the Panzer IV in 1/72 Scale by Alex Clark
Modelling the T-55 Main Battle Tank by Nicola Cortese, Graeme Davidson & Sam Dwyer
Modelling US Army Tank Destroyers of World War by Steven J. Zaloga
Panthers and Tigers on Kursk Bulge 1943 by Maksym Kolomyjec and Janusz Ledwoch
Panzer Tactics by Wolfgang Schneider
Panzerkampfwagen III by Rodrigo Hernandez Cabos and John Prigent
Panzerkampfwagen VI Tiger by Rodrigo Hernandez Cabos and John Prigent
Panzers in the Gunsights by Steven J. Zaloga
Panzerwrecks 1 by Lee Archer and William Auerbach
Panzerwrecks 2 by Lee Archer and William Auerbach
Pershing/Patton in Action by Jim Mesko
Revell Germany 1/35 Leopard 1A5
Revell Germany 1/72 TPz1 Fuchs
Sherman at War (2) The US Army in the European Theater 1943-45 by Steven J. Zaloga
Standard Catalog of German Military Vehicles by David Doyle
SU-85/100/122 by Mikhail Baryatinsky
T-72/T-72M/M1 Soviet Main Battle Tank in Detail by Frantisek Koran, et al.
Tamiya T-55A Russian Medium Tank
Tanks in Chechniya by M. Baryatinsky
Trumpeter Strv 103B MBT (S-Tank)
US Armor Camouflage and Markings World War II by Jim Mesko
US Light Tanks at War 1941-45 by Steven J. Zaloga
U.S. Military Vehicles Field Guide by David Doyle
Ultracast American Tank Crewman (Europe 1943-45)
Wehrmacht Panzer Divisions 1939-1945 by Chris Bishop
World War II Order of Battle, U.S. Army (Revised Edition) by Shelby Stanton
WWII Productions Pz. IIL Luchs Track Links
WWII Productions T-54/T-55 Track Links
WWII Productions T81 Track Links for M26 Pershing

Reviewed by Don Van Duzen

Kit #35257  1/35 Scale

injection-moulded with vinyl tracks

MSRP approx. $74.95 CDN

Few non-German WWII  AFV kits have generated the fervour that Tamiya's T55 has in the past few months.  Much has been written about this fine kit by numerous respected authors, and by the lack of negative press one would think that we have a perfect model in our midst!  Well, let's take a closer look.
 
This is a fine model, without question.  It has perfect fit,and captures the look of this important MBT perfectly.  The dimensions are spot on, the turret is near perfect in shape and detail and most of the fittings are simply beautiful, such as the 2-piece light guard on the glacis plate.  All of these features were the main failings of past kits of this magnificent beast.  One could build this kit on a weekend and be proud of the result.  But all of this has been seen in print before.
What has not been noted is that this kit, much like the much-maligned AMT/ESCI kit that preceded it a decade ago, is a mixture of T-54 and T-55 features with many missing and/or simplified details!  Most of these are minor and easily corrected to be sure, but this is a $50 US model ($75 CDN!) .  To put this in perspective for those WWII German AFV builders, imagine your disgust if Tamiya or Dragon released a Panther G with Tiger II  engine deck features!  This is a bit of an exaggeration, but you get the picture!

Two prominent features are poorly done oversimplifications. The glacis weld is not like any that I have examined on a T-55.  It is much too narrow and does not have the multi-layered and ground-down look of the real McCoy.  It should be shaved off and replaced with textured strip styrene.  The fuel tanks on the right fender are very nice and well detailed, but marred by big lumps of plastic intended to represent the tie down clamps that fasten them to the fenders.  The two rear tanks are joined at the "hip" with these lumps.  They do make for a quick and painless build as it is impossible to install these tanks in the wrong place, but they are not realistic at all and must painstakingly carved off.  It took me an hour to do this, and I am a very experienced  styrene hacker!  Those who are not will not be pleased to have to go through this procedure.  Replacements must then be scratchbuilt or added from the old On The Mark set or one of the new sure to be coming sets from Eduard or Part.  The real clamps attach to the fender braces between the fuel tanks and tighten down on brackets welded to the tanks, clamping them tightly to the right fender.  Many reference photos show this quite clearly.
 
The engine deck is a mix of T-55 and T-54 features.  In fact, if one were to replace the engine/fuel pump/air filter access hatch panel (the one with two hatches just behind the turret) with an appropriate T-54 version, one would have a T-54 engine deck.  With the inclusion of a turret vent dome in the box as well, we would have a very accurate T-54A!

The missing T-55 items on the deck are:
 
1. No intermediate gear vent on the right deck beside filler hatch.  This must be cut out and be built up with strip and screen.  It is not as easy as it sounds and it took me some time before I got it right.  A nice photo-etched part would be perfect here.
2. The armoured cover and grille over the main fan at the right rear should be slightly convex just left of centre.  As is, it represents the T-54 type.
3. The access doors with their corresponding sealing strips are well done, but the sealing mount strip around the radiator and rear grills is missing.  There is not much room to add it either, as it must go between the radiator and the hinges in front of it. There is just not enough space here, so good luck adding it!  This is a prominent T-55 feature,and will be on Chinese Type 69-II as well.
 
Other faults include :
4. Lack of larger wheel hubs on front wheels.  T-55s had larger front wheel bearings and a larger hub to match.  I made mine from a Trumpeter T54 idler hub, which is just the right size but has only 5 bolts, not the requisite 6.  This is not a well known feature but is shown in MILITARY MODELLING VOL 29 #15 JAN 2000.
5. Most T-55's had only 3 turret lift hooks, not 4 as on T-54's.  Just fill in the holes on turret rear and put one hook in the centre to duplicate this.            
6. The T-55 was built with enhanced NBC protection.  The vent on the T-54 roof was replaced with a fan under the turret rear and a vent on the lower right side of the turret inline with the front lift lug.  The kit gives no hint of either feature.  The fan would not be seen and  its absence forgivable, but not the vent as this is very visible.
7.  While the aperture for the coaxial machine gun is beautifully done, the machine gun itself, which should protrude prominently out of the aperture, is missing.
8. This final point is what annoyed me most about this kit and may not be a fair criticism.  The kit is marketed as a T-55A with DshK mount and MG, which are very nice indeed.  They also include an early flush loader's hatch with enhanced shielding and armour.  They also included an early drivers hatch of the T-54 type, with a separate piece of cladding to add to a later version.  But if Tamiya had included just one more part, JUST ONE, the large early flush type loader's hatch, an early T-55 could have been built!  The early T-55 is the definitive one in my mind and very distinctive.  The box art even suggests this early hatch, from the deceptive worm's-eye view.  This was the version I was determined to construct, so I built one from a combination of ESCI and TRUMPETER parts,Tamiya putty,strip,spit,sweat and a little blood!
 
Overall,this is a fine kit and I am grateful!  It is light-years ahead of any other kit ever made, or likely to be made.  I don't know what other variants Tamiya has in store, but from what I see in this box we will have a T-54 for sure, and maybe an early 1958 T-55. I also see a Tiran variant as well, since just about all other T-55 kit families have seen this Israeli upgraded type boxed. 
 
This is one of Tamiya's finest to date; I have purchased four to this date and will get more as time goes on.  Most faults are minor and require only minor surgery.  There is also the lack of many fine fittings ,brackets, etc., but all kits lack these.   Etched sets will soon be available for this model and they will, hopefully, address those shortcomings.  Part of me is glad the kit has some faults, as I do enjoy the challenge involved in correcting little details.  But I will build one out of the box just for the sheer joy of it.
Don

Return to Home

mbt70.jpg